|
|
Post by 𝕭𝖔𝖔𝖒𝖈𝖍𝖆𝖈𝖑𝖊 on Jun 5, 2017 3:18:45 GMT
I made a video with it in it and youtube states that it contains copyrighted music; "Far Centaurus - Nigel Stanford"
I dont know if this should count as copyrighted music as it is part of the game.
|
|
|
|
Post by apophys on Jun 5, 2017 4:19:02 GMT
Every creation everywhere is copyrighted, whether explicitly stated or not (such is copyright law as far as I know it). Only after a certain number of years does it pass into public domain, and that number has been extended to truly absurd times (95 to 120 years? wtf Disney), and some content is directly passed by authors into public domain. Content may or may not be released with a Creative Commons license (which many artists do, and all should, but I digress), in which case its limitations depend on the particular license. I don't think this music is released with such, but I haven't checked. If it isn't, I think the proper way to go about things is to ask the author directly for permission (people tend to be nice).
Youtube's identification of the music appears correct, by the way.
Some people are calling for the abolition of copyright as a whole, which seems an increasingly reasonable position to take. Especially with the hydra around.
(Sorry for the bit of rant.)
|
|
|
|
Post by paleblackdot on Jun 5, 2017 4:19:08 GMT
"Far Centaurus" was composed by Nigel Stanford back in 2015 (if not earlier). It is his own work - not the game's.
|
|
|
|
Post by zorbeltuss on Jun 5, 2017 9:44:34 GMT
I made a video with it in it and youtube states that it contains copyrighted music; "Far Centaurus - Nigel Stanford" I dont know if this should count as copyrighted music as it is part of the game. Well as stated it is copyrighted, that does not fully explain why the video was flagged however, it might be that Qswitched has acquired the license to have it in game but not for clips of the video containing the music appearing on a different media, it might also be that the algorithm took direct action which is uncommon but in some cases happen or that someone was too zealous in taking down videos for example people have issued dmca takedowns on themselves by mistake. Which one applies I don't know but I'd guess @qswitched should answer if he knows something before we inquire through other routes. |
|
|
|
Post by Enderminion on Jun 5, 2017 13:53:23 GMT
I made a video with it in it and youtube states that it contains copyrighted music; "Far Centaurus - Nigel Stanford" I dont know if this should count as copyrighted music as it is part of the game. Well as stated it is copyrighted, that does not fully explain why the video was flagged however, it might be that Qswitched has acquired the license to have it in game but not for clips of the video containing the music appearing on a different media, it might also be that the algorithm took direct action which is uncommon but in some cases happen or that someone was too zealous in taking down videos for example people have issued dmca takedowns on themselves by mistake. Which one applies I don't know but I'd guess @qswitched should answer if he knows something before we inquire through other routes. its @Admin
qswitched to tag qswitched |
|
|
|
Post by qswitched on Jun 11, 2017 18:48:33 GMT
I made a video with it in it and youtube states that it contains copyrighted music; "Far Centaurus - Nigel Stanford" I dont know if this should count as copyrighted music as it is part of the game. Well as stated it is copyrighted, that does not fully explain why the video was flagged however, it might be that Qswitched has acquired the license to have it in game but not for clips of the video containing the music appearing on a different media, it might also be that the algorithm took direct action which is uncommon but in some cases happen or that someone was too zealous in taking down videos for example people have issued dmca takedowns on themselves by mistake. Which one applies I don't know but I'd guess @qswitched should answer if he knows something before we inquire through other routes. Nigel Stanford owns the music's copyright. Children of a Dead Earth only licenses it. |
|
